House Speaker Paul Ryan says the nation has just two options. It can accept his repeal and replace bill or it can keep the mess it already has. “It really comes down to a binary choice,” he said, trying to whip recalcitrant conservatives into line behind the American Health Care Act. “This is the closest we will ever get to repealing and replacing Obamacare.”

Many House Republicans are persuaded. So are some conservative commentators and activists. But they are mistaken because Ryan’s logic is faulty.

Our friends at the Wall Street Journal editorial page endorsed the AHCA on Wednesday, focusing mostly on the tax cuts in the bill. Tax cuts are indeed an attractive feature of the legislation, but voters delivered neither House and Senate majorities to the GOP nor President Trump’s stunning victory so that united government could deliver a narrow victory of lower tax rates for big corporations. Nor were lower taxes on capital gains and medical devices what ignited voters’ support for Republicans. They wanted something bigger and more sweeping than that.

The journal argued that conservative critics of the House repeal and replace bill are “missing the larger and rarer opportunity,” and added, “ObamaCare was designed to expand over time … If conservatives fumble this repeal-and-replace moment, they won’t get another chance.”

This is true as far as it goes, but just because the time is right to repeal and replace does not mean Ryan’s bill is the right way to do it. His premise of “a binary choice” is not true.

There’s another option. Republicans could pass a better Obamacare replacement, one that doesn’t preserve costly regulations or create a brand new entitlement.

Interesting Read…

See Also:

Lying Congress and the lying anti-repealers

Conservatives clamor for Trump to dump ‘Ryancare’

Hundreds of Tea Party Activists Brave Cold Winds to Demand Repeal of Obamacare

Republican Leadership Considers Removing ‘Premium Surcharge’ Mandate in Healthcare Replacement Bill

Speaker Paul Ryan’s Parliamentarian Straw Woman

Trump’s finest hour nears

Donald Trump Budget Spends Big on Military and the Wall; Cuts Foreign Aid, EPA, and Public Broadcasting

Hawaii Judge Puts Travel Ban on Hold, Trump Lashes Back

Trump was wrong to try to appease courts on entry ban

Dershowitz: Travel Ban Ruling Shows Cleaning It Up Is ‘Futile’

Donald Trump Fumes Against ‘Judicial Overreach’ After Immigration Order Blocked Again

Judges Inventing New Reasons to Obstruct Donald Trump’s Popular Immigration Reforms

Hawaii Obama Judge Rules Muslim Imam Has Special Constitutional Rights to Bring Anyone from Terror Countries into America

Trump Details Big Plans in Detroit: ‘The Assault on the American Auto Industry is Over’

“Peter Pan” Warns Trump About NAFTA Plan, Says Deal Is Good for U.S. Jobs

Tillerson tells UN Human Rights Council: Reform or US will leave

Sessions Calls for New Anti-Drug Education Like in ’80s and ’90s

Do Trade Deficits Matter? – The Debate Heats Up

Stock Market Rises as Fed Chair Janet Yellen Urges Congress and Trump Administration to Adopt Pro-Growth Policies


(Visited 5 times, 1 visits today)